It is currently Thu Oct 18, 2018 4:11 am




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 2 posts ] 
 Aristotelian Thomism 
Author Message

Joined: Fri Oct 28, 2011 3:40 am
Posts: 438
Location: Tucson, Arizona
New post Aristotelian Thomism
Aristotelian Thomism
From Edward Feser's "The Thomistic Tradition (part 1)" (vide also part 2):
Quote:
This approach emphasizes the Aristotelian foundations of Aquinas’s philosophy, and in particular the idea that the construction of a sound metaphysics must be preceded by a sound understanding of natural science, as interpreted in light of an Aristotelian philosophy of nature. Accordingly, it is keen to show that modern physical science can and should be given such an interpretation. Charles De Koninck (1906-1965), James A. Weisheipl (1923-1984), William A. Wallace, and Benedict Ashley are among its representatives. It is sometimes called “Laval Thomism” after the University of Laval in Quebec [which produced this brilliant thesis: Thomism and Mathematical Physics], where De Koninck was a professor. The alternative label “River Forest Thomism” derives from a suburb of Chicago, the location of the Albertus Magnus Lyceum for Natural Science, whose members are associated with this approach. It is also sometimes called “Aristotelian Thomism” (to highlight its contrast with Gilson’s brand of existential Thomism) though since Neo-Scholastic Thomism also emphasizes Aquinas’s continuity with Aristotle, this label seems a bit too proprietary. (There are writers, like the contemporary Thomist Ralph McInerny, who exhibit both Neo-Scholastic and Laval/River Forest influences, and the approaches are not necessarily incompatible.)
See also: E.g., Heisenberg recognized in his Physics and Philosophy that the probability wave concept in quantum mechanics "was a quantitative version of the concept of 'potentia' in Aristotelian philosophy" (p. 41) and that the "concept of the soul for instance in the philosophy of Thomas Aquinas was more natural and less forced than the Cartesian concept of 'res cogitans,' even if we are convinced that the laws of physics and chemistry are strictly valid in living organisms." (p. 80).

Physics and Quantum in The Thomist
These are some of the physics- and quantum-related articles from The Thomist, roughly sorted in terms of decreasing relevance with the most relevant first:
  1. From Schrödinger's Cat to Thomistic Ontology by Wolfgang Smith
  2. Natural Motion in Inanimate Bodies by Thomas Larson
  3. The Natural Motion of Matter in Newtonian and Post-Newtonian Physics John W. Keck
  4. Aristotle's Aether and Contemporary Science by Christopher A. Decaen
    1. Cf. Steven Baldner's "Thomas Aquinas on Celestial Matter;" this and Decaen's article are crucial for understanding the Galileo affair and
    2. Decaen's lecture "Galileo Galilei, Scriptural Exegete, and the Church of Rome, Advocate of Science."
  5. Quantum Mechanics: A Dialectical Approach to Reality by Wojciech P. Grygiel, F.S.S.P.
  6. Elemental Virtual Presence in St. Thomas by Christopher Decaen
    1. The Principles of Nature by St. Thomas Aquinas
  7. St. Thomas, Physics, and the Principle of Metaphysics by Lawrence Dewan, O.P.
    1. Reply of Benedict Ashley, O.P.
    2. For a definitive reply to Dewan, see Benedict Ashley, O.P.'s excellent overview of Aristotelian Thomism and how the natural sciences are epistemologically first: The Way toward Wisdom (p. 146-163) or "The River Forest School and the Philosophy of Nature Today"
    3. Cf. also "Physics & Metaphysics" by Pierre Duhem
    Part and Whole in Aristotle's Concept of Infinity by David A. White
  8. Thomism and the Quantum Enigma by William A. Wallace, O.P.
    1. William Wallace, O.P., refers to this in his excellent book The Modeling of Nature
  9. Modern Physics and Thomist Philosophy by E. F. Caldin
  10. Space-Time and the Community of Beings: Some Cosmological Speculations by George A. Kendall
  11. The Metaphysics of Chaos: A Thomistic View of Entropy and Evolution by Wojciech P. Grygiel, F.S.S.P.
  12. Reconciling Science with Natural Philosophy by Michael Augros
  13. The Law of Inertia and the Principle Quidquid Movetur ab Alio Movetur by Antonio Moreno, O.P.
  14. Time and Relativity: Some Philosophical Considerations by Antonio Moreno, O.P.
  15. Thomas and the Universe by Stanley L. Jaki
  16. Cantor's Transfinite Numbers and Traditional Objections to Actual Infinity by Jean W. Rioux
  17. Thomism and Modern Science: Relationships Past, Present, and Future by William A. Wallace, O.P.

Scholasticism in Empiriological Sciences
From footnote †7 on pg. 24 of St. Thomas Aquinas's Division and methods of the sciences, a commentary on Boethius's De Trinitate questions V and VI, translator Armand Maurer mentions these articles relating Scholasticism to empiriological sciences like modern physics.
Quote:
The growth in modern times of empiriological science, as distinct from philosophy in its formal object and method, renders impossible a physical theory that would be applicable in a univocal way to both. Such a theory, which denies the distinction between philosophical and empiriological analysis, has been proposed by R. Nogar, "Toward a Physical Theory," The New Scholasticism 25 (1951), 397-438.

J. Weisheipl proposes a return to St. Thomas and St. Albert for "a unifying physical theory" that would include both the philosophy of nature and the empirical or experimental sciences. For Weisheipl these constitute one specific discipline, both materially and formally. However, he regards the sciences employing mathematical principles as really distinct from natural philosophy. See J. Weisheipl, The Development of Physical Theory in the Middle Ages; "The Relationship of Medieval Natural Philosophy to Modern Science: The Contribution of Thomas Aquinas to Its Understanding," in Science. Medicine and the Universities 1200-1550. Essays in Honor of Pearl Kibre (= Manuscripta 20 [1976]), pp. 181-196; idem, Introduction to The Dignity of Science. Studies in the Philosophy of Science Presented to William Humbert Kane OP (= The Thomist 24 [1961]).

In the same spirit, see C. De Koninck, "The Unity and Diversity of Natural Science," in The Philosophy of Physics, ed. V. E. Smith, pp. 5-24; W. A. Wallace, "St. Thomas's Conception of Natural Philosophy and its Method," in Studi Tomistici. La philosophie de la nature de saint Thomas d'Aquin, ed. L. Elders, pp. 7-27; idem, Causality and Scientific Explanation [cf. idem, Review of Metaphysics 27:3 (March 1974)].

For further discussions of this topic, see E. McMullin, "Philosophies of Nature," The New Scholasticism 43 (1969), 29-74; J. Compton, "Reinventing the Philosophy of Nature," The Review of Metaphysics 33 (1979), 3-28; E. McMullin, "Compton on the Philosophy of Nature," ibid., pp. 29-58; idem, "Is There a Philosophy of Nature?" Proceedings of the International Congress of Philosophy, Vienna, 1968, 4: 295-305.
This is what the Society of Scholastics and the Institute for Advanced Physics seek to promote. See also the Society of Scholastic's Constitution, Thomas Aquinas College's founding document, the 24 Thomistic Theses with P. Lumbreras, O.P.'s commentary, and especially the works on which I have commented here.

Thomism
St. Thomas Aquinas in English and in Latin: Opera Omnia, Leonine edition (1882): tomes 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 Natural philosophy books:
  1. Modern Thomistic Philosophy by Richard Percival Phillips
  2. The Physical System of St. Thomas by Giovanni Maria Cornoldi
  3. Philosophical Physics by Vincent Edward Smith
  4. Thomism and Mathematical Physics, a thesis by Bernard I. Mullahy
  5. The Principles of Nature, Commentary on Aristotle's Posterior Analytics, and Commentary on Aristotle's Physics by St. Thomas Aquinas
Other:
  1. Pope Leo XIII's encyclical Æterni Patris (in Latin here) on the restoration of Thomism
  2. A Scholastic List of Definitions for Philosophical Terms and of Philosophical Axioms
  3. Question 1 of the Summa Theologica by St. Thomas Aquinas
  4. The natural sciences are epistemologically first according to Aristotelian Thomism.
  5. "The Philosophy of Nature" by Joseph Kenny, O.P.
  6. Four Ages of Understanding by John Deely, an excellent history of philosophy (vide this review)

Contra Scientism
  1. The Plague of Scientistic Belief by Wolfgang Smith
  2. "Physics & Metaphysics," "Physics of a Believer," and excerpt from To Save the Phenomena by Pierre Duhem (vide also his biography and these papers on his physics)
  3. The Problem of Mechanism by David L. Schindler
  4. The structure of the encyclical "Humani Generis" by Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P.

Faith & Reason
On the differences and similarities between faith—"a kind of knowledge, inasmuch as the intellect is determined by faith to some knowable object" (Summa Theologiæ, Iª q. 12 a. 13 ad 3)—and reason, read:
  1. Philosophy & Catholic Theology: A Primer by Philip A. Egan, Chapter 1
  2. Reason and Faith from TruthInspire
  3. "Faith and Reason" from Étienne Gilson's The Philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas (criticism)
  4. "The Dream of Natural Philosophy" by Brian Mullady, O.P.
  5. Fives Ways to Prove God's Existence by St. Thomas Aquinas
  6. On Faith and Reason from Vatican I's Dei Filius

Biographies
Biographies mostly of perhaps lesser-known yet still very innovative [mostly Catholic] scientists, from the Dictionary of Scientific Biography

WorldCat Lists
Visit my WorldCat list on Aristotelian Thomism. It includes many more books and articles pertaining to the relationship between Aristotelian-Thomistic scholastic philosophy and the empiriological sciences like modern physics. Also, see my "History of Science", "History of Philosophy", "Catholic", and "Thomism" WorldCat lists.

Click here to return to my homepage.

_________________
«The Essence & Topicality of Thomism»: http://ar.gy/5AaP
by Fr. Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P.
e-Book: bit.ly/1iDkMAw

Modernism: modernism. us.to
blog: sententiaedeo.blogspot. com
Aristotelian Thomism: scholastic. us.to


Last edited by Alan Aversa on Thu Nov 10, 2011 12:52 am, edited 1 time in total.

Tue Nov 01, 2011 12:09 am
Profile E-mail

Joined: Fri Oct 28, 2011 3:40 am
Posts: 438
Location: Tucson, Arizona
New post Re: Aristotelian Thomism
Alan Aversa wrote:
Aristotelian Thomism
From Edward Feser's "The Thomistic Tradition (part 1)" (vide also part 2):
Quote:
This approach emphasizes the Aristotelian foundations of Aquinas’s philosophy, and in particular the idea that the construction of a sound metaphysics must be preceded by a sound understanding of natural science, as interpreted in light of an Aristotelian philosophy of nature. Accordingly, it is keen to show that modern physical science can and should be given such an interpretation. Charles De Koninck (1906-1965), James A. Weisheipl (1923-1984), William A. Wallace, and Benedict Ashley are among its representatives. It is sometimes called “Laval Thomism” after the University of Laval in Quebec [which produced this brilliant thesis: Thomism and Mathematical Physics], where De Koninck was a professor. The alternative label “River Forest Thomism” derives from a suburb of Chicago, the location of the Albertus Magnus Lyceum for Natural Science, whose members are associated with this approach. It is also sometimes called “Aristotelian Thomism” (to highlight its contrast with Gilson’s brand of existential Thomism) though since Neo-Scholastic Thomism also emphasizes Aquinas’s continuity with Aristotle, this label seems a bit too proprietary. (There are writers, like the contemporary Thomist Ralph McInerny, who exhibit both Neo-Scholastic and Laval/River Forest influences, and the approaches are not necessarily incompatible.)
See also: E.g., Heisenberg recognized in his Physics and Philosophy that the probability wave concept in quantum mechanics "was a quantitative version of the concept of 'potentia' in Aristotelian philosophy" (p. 41) and that the "concept of the soul for instance in the philosophy of Thomas Aquinas was more natural and less forced than the Cartesian concept of 'res cogitans,' even if we are convinced that the laws of physics and chemistry are strictly valid in living organisms." (p. 80).

Physics and Quantum in The Thomist
These are some of the physics- and quantum-related articles from The Thomist, roughly sorted in terms of decreasing relevance with the most relevant first:
  1. From Schrödinger's Cat to Thomistic Ontology by Wolfgang Smith
  2. Natural Motion in Inanimate Bodies by Thomas Larson
  3. The Natural Motion of Matter in Newtonian and Post-Newtonian Physics John W. Keck
  4. Aristotle's Aether and Contemporary Science by Christopher A. Decaen
    1. Cf. Steven Baldner's "Thomas Aquinas on Celestial Matter;" this and Decaen's article are crucial for understanding the Galileo affair and
    2. Decaen's lecture "Galileo Galilei, Scriptural Exegete, and the Church of Rome, Advocate of Science."
  5. Quantum Mechanics: A Dialectical Approach to Reality by Wojciech P. Grygiel, F.S.S.P.
  6. Elemental Virtual Presence in St. Thomas by Christopher Decaen
    1. The Principles of Nature by St. Thomas Aquinas
  7. St. Thomas, Physics, and the Principle of Metaphysics by Lawrence Dewan, O.P.
    1. Reply of Benedict Ashley, O.P.
    2. For a definitive reply to Dewan, see Benedict Ashley, O.P.'s excellent overview of Aristotelian Thomism and how the natural sciences are epistemologically first: The Way toward Wisdom (p. 146-163) or "The River Forest School and the Philosophy of Nature Today"
    3. Cf. also "Physics & Metaphysics" by Pierre Duhem
    Part and Whole in Aristotle's Concept of Infinity by David A. White
  8. Thomism and the Quantum Enigma by William A. Wallace, O.P.
    1. William Wallace, O.P., refers to this in his excellent book The Modeling of Nature
  9. Modern Physics and Thomist Philosophy by E. F. Caldin
  10. Space-Time and the Community of Beings: Some Cosmological Speculations by George A. Kendall
  11. The Metaphysics of Chaos: A Thomistic View of Entropy and Evolution by Wojciech P. Grygiel, F.S.S.P.
  12. Reconciling Science with Natural Philosophy by Michael Augros
  13. The Law of Inertia and the Principle Quidquid Movetur ab Alio Movetur by Antonio Moreno, O.P.
  14. Time and Relativity: Some Philosophical Considerations by Antonio Moreno, O.P.
  15. Thomas and the Universe by Stanley L. Jaki
  16. Cantor's Transfinite Numbers and Traditional Objections to Actual Infinity by Jean W. Rioux
  17. Thomism and Modern Science: Relationships Past, Present, and Future by William A. Wallace, O.P.

Scholasticism in Empiriological Sciences
From footnote †7 on pg. 24 of St. Thomas Aquinas's Division and methods of the sciences, a commentary on Boethius's De Trinitate questions V and VI, translator Armand Maurer mentions these articles relating Scholasticism to empiriological sciences like modern physics.
Quote:
The growth in modern times of empiriological science, as distinct from philosophy in its formal object and method, renders impossible a physical theory that would be applicable in a univocal way to both. Such a theory, which denies the distinction between philosophical and empiriological analysis, has been proposed by R. Nogar, "Toward a Physical Theory," The New Scholasticism 25 (1951), 397-438.

J. Weisheipl proposes a return to St. Thomas and St. Albert for "a unifying physical theory" that would include both the philosophy of nature and the empirical or experimental sciences. For Weisheipl these constitute one specific discipline, both materially and formally. However, he regards the sciences employing mathematical principles as really distinct from natural philosophy. See J. Weisheipl, The Development of Physical Theory in the Middle Ages; "The Relationship of Medieval Natural Philosophy to Modern Science: The Contribution of Thomas Aquinas to Its Understanding," in Science. Medicine and the Universities 1200-1550. Essays in Honor of Pearl Kibre (= Manuscripta 20 [1976]), pp. 181-196; idem, Introduction to The Dignity of Science. Studies in the Philosophy of Science Presented to William Humbert Kane OP (= The Thomist 24 [1961]).

In the same spirit, see C. De Koninck, "The Unity and Diversity of Natural Science," in The Philosophy of Physics, ed. V. E. Smith, pp. 5-24; W. A. Wallace, "St. Thomas's Conception of Natural Philosophy and its Method," in Studi Tomistici. La philosophie de la nature de saint Thomas d'Aquin, ed. L. Elders, pp. 7-27; idem, Causality and Scientific Explanation [cf. idem, Review of Metaphysics 27:3 (March 1974)].

For further discussions of this topic, see E. McMullin, "Philosophies of Nature," The New Scholasticism 43 (1969), 29-74; J. Compton, "Reinventing the Philosophy of Nature," The Review of Metaphysics 33 (1979), 3-28; E. McMullin, "Compton on the Philosophy of Nature," ibid., pp. 29-58; idem, "Is There a Philosophy of Nature?" Proceedings of the International Congress of Philosophy, Vienna, 1968, 4: 295-305.
This is what the Society of Scholastics and the Institute for Advanced Physics seek to promote. See also the Society of Scholastic's Constitution, Thomas Aquinas College's founding document, the 24 Thomistic Theses with P. Lumbreras, O.P.'s commentary, and especially the works on which I have commented here.

Thomism
St. Thomas Aquinas in English and in Latin: Opera Omnia, Leonine edition (1882): tomes 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 Natural philosophy books:
  1. Modern Thomistic Philosophy by Richard Percival Phillips
  2. The Physical System of St. Thomas by Giovanni Maria Cornoldi
  3. Philosophical Physics by Vincent Edward Smith
  4. Thomism and Mathematical Physics, a thesis by Bernard I. Mullahy
  5. The Principles of Nature, Commentary on Aristotle's Posterior Analytics, and Commentary on Aristotle's Physics by St. Thomas Aquinas
Other:
  1. Pope Leo XIII's encyclical Æterni Patris (in Latin here) on the restoration of Thomism
  2. A Scholastic List of Definitions for Philosophical Terms and of Philosophical Axioms
  3. Question 1 of the Summa Theologica by St. Thomas Aquinas
  4. The natural sciences are epistemologically first according to Aristotelian Thomism.
  5. "The Philosophy of Nature" by Joseph Kenny, O.P.
  6. Four Ages of Understanding by John Deely, an excellent history of philosophy (vide this review)

Contra Scientism
  1. The Plague of Scientistic Belief by Wolfgang Smith
  2. "Physics & Metaphysics," "Physics of a Believer," and excerpt from To Save the Phenomena by Pierre Duhem (vide also his biography and these papers on his physics)
  3. The Problem of Mechanism by David L. Schindler
  4. The structure of the encyclical "Humani Generis" by Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P.

Faith & Reason
On the differences and similarities between faith—"a kind of knowledge, inasmuch as the intellect is determined by faith to some knowable object" (Summa Theologiæ, Iª q. 12 a. 13 ad 3)—and reason, read:
  1. Philosophy & Catholic Theology: A Primer by Philip A. Egan, Chapter 1
  2. Reason and Faith from TruthInspire
  3. "Faith and Reason" from Étienne Gilson's The Philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas (criticism)
  4. "The Dream of Natural Philosophy" by Brian Mullady, O.P.
  5. Fives Ways to Prove God's Existence by St. Thomas Aquinas
  6. On Faith and Reason from Vatican I's Dei Filius

Biographies
Biographies mostly of perhaps lesser-known yet still very innovative [mostly Catholic] scientists, from the Dictionary of Scientific Biography

WorldCat Lists
Visit my WorldCat list on Aristotelian Thomism. It includes many more books and articles pertaining to the relationship between Aristotelian-Thomistic scholastic philosophy and the empiriological sciences like modern physics. Also, see my "History of Science", "History of Philosophy", "Catholic", and "Thomism" WorldCat lists.

Click here to return to my homepage.

_________________
«The Essence & Topicality of Thomism»: http://ar.gy/5AaP
by Fr. Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange, O.P.
e-Book: bit.ly/1iDkMAw

Modernism: modernism. us.to
blog: sententiaedeo.blogspot. com
Aristotelian Thomism: scholastic. us.to


Mon Nov 07, 2011 4:32 am
Profile E-mail
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 2 posts ] 


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group.
Designed by Vjacheslav Trushkin for Free Forums/DivisionCore.